Linea Aeropostal Venezolana Flight 253 (June 1956)

Not to be confused with Linea Aeropostal Venezolana Flight 253 (November 1956).

Linea Aeropostal Venezolana Flight 253

350px A Super constellation similar to the accident aircraft
Accident summary
Date	June 20, 1956 (1956-06-20)
Summary	Loss of control after fire
Site	Atlantic Ocean, off New Jersey, USA
Passengers	64
Crew	10
Fatalities	74 (all)
Survivors	0
Aircraft type	Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation
Operator	Linea Aeropostal Venezolana
Registration	YV-C-AMS
Flight origin	New York-Idlewild International Airport (IDL/KIDL)
Destination	Caracas-Simón Bolívar International Airport (CCS/SVMI)

Linea Aeropostal Venezolana Flight 253 was a regularly scheduled passenger flight from Idlewild International Airport, New York bound for Caracas International Airport, Caracas, Venezuela on 20 June 1956. Approximately one hour and twenty minutes after departure, the flight crew reported trouble with one of the engines and turned back to New York. While dumping fuel in preparation for landing, the airplane, a Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation, caught fire and plummeted into the Atlantic Ocean off Asbury Park, New Jersey. All 74 aboard were killed; at the time, it was the world's deadliest disaster involving a scheduled commercial flight. However, its death toll would soon be surpassed only ten days later.

The flight

The flight was being operated by a Lockheed L-1049 Super Constellation, registration YV-C-AMS named "Rafael Urdaneta", under the command of Captain Luis F. Plata. The plane departed New York at approximately 11:15 p.m. on June 19. At 12:20 a.m. on June 20, some 250 miles east of Norfolk, Virginia, Captain Plata reported that the Number 2 propeller − the inboard one on the port (left) wing − was overspeeding and radioed his intent to return to Idlewild. Twenty minutes later, the crew declared an emergency, stating that they had been unable to feather the #2 propeller. An Eastern Airlines flight operated by Captain Charles Fisher, bound from New York to San Juan, diverted to monitor the situation and assist in relaying communications, while a U. S. Coast Guard aircraft piloted by LCdr Frederick Hancox was dispatched to escort the stricken airliner back to New York.

By 1:25 a.m. the Super Constellation, with its escorts in tow, was off the coast of New Jersey, beginning its descent to New York. Captain Plata requested and received permission to dump fuel, which began at 1:29. Almost immediately, the crews of both escort aircraft observed the streaming fuel catch fire and erupt in a large fireball. The airliner swerved violently to the right, nosed over and plunged into the sea, exploding on impact. Commander Hancox reported its rate of descent was 4,000 feet per minute and that it was in a 90-degree bank at the moment of impact. Captain Fisher described the descent of the blazing aircraft as like "a falling star."

The accident occurred 32 miles east of Asbury Park, New Jersey. The Coast Guard plane circled the flaming wreckage, but could see no signs of life, only aircraft debris along with pieces of clothing and personal effects. The Navy transport Lt. Robert Craig, the first surface ship to arrive, was on scene at 3:43 a.m. and radioed: "Found no survivors. Expect to find none." Crews dispatched from the Craig in lifeboats recovered only fragments of bodies along with various debris. By dawn, any wreckage not recovered had sunk in 120 feet of water.

Investigation and aftermath

The debris and remains recovered the night of the crash provided no clues to the origin of the sudden fire; initial speculation was that fuel vapor may have come into contact with hot exhaust gases from one or more engines. Locating the main wreckage proved difficult due to the relatively wide dispersion of the debris - Hancox had observed the airliner shed flaming parts during its descent, and the final impact and explosion were described as violent, strewing debris over a considerable area. U. S. Navy salvage teams dragged grappling lines across the site for several days without success. Finally, a June 30 sonar search provided tentative identification of the main wreckage, which the Navy estimated would require "days or weeks" to raise. Minimal progress was made over the ensuing week, largely due to bad weather; On July 6, the Venezuelan government requested that recovery operations be halted.

The investigation spent considerable time analyzing the events of the fuel dump in order to identify the likeliest source of the ignition. Hancox reported that as soon as Captain Plata commenced dumping fuel, he observed sparks and flame in the vicinity of the Number 3 engine, the inboard engine on the starboard (right) wing, opposite the engine with the propeller problem. The investigative board concluded that the vibration induced by the runaway Number 2 propeller had caused internal structural damage to the starboard wing behind the Number 3 engine, between the fuel tank and fuel dump chute, as this area would have been the symmetrical point of the vibration. The board considered this the most probable cause, but stated that it was unable to determine this with certainty.

Ruth Noel, widow of passenger Marshal L. Noel, subsequently sought damages from both the airline and United Aircraft (owners of Hamilton Standard, the manufacturer of the failed propeller.) In the course of the litigation, evidence was introduced that within moments of the fuel dump commencing, the faulty Number 2 propeller broke free of its mountings and slashed into the fuselage. The double seat in the area of the impact was apparently ejected from the aircraft at this time, as it was found some distance from the spot where YV-C-AMS crashed; it had been cut in half from top to bottom by a heavy object. The bodies of its two occupants were among the few recovered from the scene; both had suffered leg amputations. Expert testimony provided two possible scenarios for ignition of the jettisoning fuel:

• When the Number 2 propeller separated, the airstream blew sparks from its broken hub or shaft backwards into the plume of fuel;
• When the Number 2 propeller slashed downward through the fuselage, it sliced through the cabin floor into the #5 fuel tank (center tank), immediately igniting the fuel within. The flames blew out of the fuselage into the fuel plume.

In May 1959, propeller pitch-lock mechanisms, designed to arrest the pitch of the blades and prevent them from opening further when an overspeed is imminent, became mandatory on U.S. piston-engined transport aircraft.

Second crash

Six months later, Flight 253 again ended in tragedy, when it crashed into a mountain on approach to Caracas. All 25 aboard were killed.